Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (2024)

When you use our simple pizza dough (or a good store-bought one), making any of these pizza recipes is as easy as pie. Go classic with your toppings, or get creative, as we did, taking a cue from antipasto platters, popular salads, and so much more. The possibilities are endless, which means any night can be pizza night.

First and foremost, you'll need your base, so start with one of our basic pizza dough recipes. If you're planning to make pizza on a weeknight, we suggest making the dough the night before and storing it in the refrigerator. Then, let it work its magic.

While these pizzas can cook on either a pizza stone or a baking sheet, we're also a fan of using a cast-iron skillet to make homemade pies. By cooking the pizza dough in this pan, the crust becomes golden brown and so crispy.

From thin crust to deep dish, vegetarian to meat lover's, our pizza recipes are sure to make you say, "Mamma Mia, that's amore!"

01of 38

Sausage, Mushroom, and Pickled-Pepper Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (1)

The pie offers a little bit of everything. Take in the big pop of flavor and color from fresh basil, pickled cherry peppers, and shiitake mushroom caps. Fresh basil and a low-moisture mozzarella offset some of the sharp, savory toppings.

View Recipe

02of 38

Classic Margherita Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (2)

Classic. Timeless. A tried-and-true favorite. Absolutely perfect. There are so many ways to describe this simple tomato-mozzarella-basil pizza, but two words should do the trick—that's amore!

View Recipe

03of 38

Roman-Style Thin-Crust Pizzas

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (3)

Thin and crispy, these pizzas are sure to disappear in a flash. Try any or all of the three toppings we outlined in this recipe: There's Spinach-Parmigiano-Pepper Flakes, Potato-Red Onion-Arugula, and Ricotta-Peas-Prosciutto, which is pictured here.

View Recipe

04of 38

Grandma-Style Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (4)

Similar to Sicilian-style pizza, this thicker pie is topped with an entire pound of mozzarella cheese, cremini mushrooms, and sliced pepperoni. Feel free to leave off the meat for a vegetarian meal.

View Recipe

05of 38

White Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (5)

Skip the sauce and let the cheese shine in this understated pizza topped with a duo of shredded Fontina cheese and fresh mozzarella.

View Recipe

06of 38

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (6)

One roasted chicken breast yields all the meat you need for two of these pizzas. The meat is tossed with barbecue sauce and teamed with sharp white cheddar and sweet red onions for an irresistible topping.

View Recipe

07of 38

Flag Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (7)

Pay homage to the flag with this festive pie! Blue potatoes and fresh mozzarella pearls form the "stars" while cherry tomatoes stand in for the "stripes."

View Recipe

08of 38

Deep-Dish Meatball Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (8)

Kids and adults alike will love this hearty pizza. Homemade meatballs and marinara top store-bought dough.

View Recipe

09of 38

Cauliflower Crust Pizza Margherita

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (9)

Cauliflower is blitzed in the food processor, then turned into a gluten-free pizza dough with an assist from an egg and two types of cheese—mozzarella and Grana Padano. The resulting golden crust is finished with more mozzarella, roasted cherry tomatoes, and fresh basil.

10of 38

Vegetable Lovers' Deep-Dish Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (10)

The vibrant colors and crisp texture of fresh vegetables like bell peppers and broccolini top the ultimate vegetarian pizza. We have a feeling that carnivores are going to want to dig in, too.

View Recipe

11of 38

Cheesy Chicken-and-Corn Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (11)

Put leftover rotisserie chicken to good use in this pie that builds a powerful, flavor-packed team of spicy tomatillo salsa, sour cream, Monterey Jack, and fresh corn kernels.

View Recipe

12of 38

Grilled Vegetable Pizzas

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (12)

Make use of a bounty of hearty vegetables—such as shiitake mushrooms, lacinato kale, and red onions—with this colorful grilled pizza recipe. As for the cheese, get ready for a punchy combination of blue cheese and low-moisture mozzarella.

View Recipe

13of 38

Wild Mushroom Skillet Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (13)

This skillet pizza recipe starts by sautéing mixed wild mushrooms with butter and shallots until the 'shrooms are golden brown. White wine and heavy cream are added, and then the whole mixture is spooned over fresh pizza dough topped with Fontina cheese.

View Recipe

14of 38

White Pizza with Pickled Onions and Peppers

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (14)

You'll go heart eyes for this bright pink and red pizza that gets its color from thinly sliced soppressata and a tangy combination of homemade pickled onions and peppers. But the flavor doesn't stop there! We added a trio of cheeses—ricotta, Parmesan, and Monterey Jack—to finish it all off.

View Recipe

15of 38

Nicoise-Salad Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (15)

Inspired by the traditional French salad, this pizza—which is cooked on a baking sheet—is topped with thinly sliced potatoes, black olives, oil-packed tuna, haricots verts, red onions, and a sprinkle of baby arugula.

View Recipe

16of 38

Escarole, Provolone, and Cherry-Tomato Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (16)

This vegetarian pizza recipe features an exciting combination of escarole, radicchio, and halved cherry tomatoes, plus capers and ooey-gooey provolone cheese slices.

View Recipe

17of 38

Two-Tomato Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (17)

This is no ordinary vegan pizza recipe—one half is covered with freshly puréed red tomatoes, while the other half is topped with puréed yellow tomatoes. It's a stunning visual contrast that everyone will enjoy.

View Recipe

18of 38

Prosciutto Mozzarella Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (18)

Dress up this white pizza with thin slices of salty prosciutto, an irresistible melt-in-your-mouth treat that offers a taste of Italy.

View Recipe

19of 38

Squash-Blossom Pizzas

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (19)

Sunny yellow squash blossoms and zucchini crown these show-stopping pizzas. Crack an egg over the top in the last five minutes of baking to take them to the next level.

View Recipe

20of 38

Antipasto-Platter Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (20)

Combine the appetizer and main course with this creative pie. Sliced Italian meats, including mortadella and capocollo, top our favorite fast pizza dough alongside tangy pepperoncini, marinated green olives, and artichoke hearts.

View Recipe

21of 38

Artichoke-and-Spinach Skillet Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (21)

A preheated cast-iron skillet is the key to getting a restaurant-quality crust in this weeknight-friendly pizza. Two types of cheese—ricotta and mozzarella—and good-for-you spinach and artichoke hearts complete the dish.

View Recipe

22of 38

Pepperoni Three-Cheese White Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (22)

This recipe is an upgrade of one of the most timeless pies. A to-die-for white sauce is made from heavy cream, Parmigiano, garlic, and lemon. Top with dollops of ricotta, sliced mozzarella, and pepperoni, then finish off the final product with an extra drizzle of olive oil and a few cranks of black pepper.

View Recipe

23of 38

Sausage-and-Fontina Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (23)

This salad-inspired pizza is topped with baby arugula, sliced fennel, and shaved carrots after it has finished baking. It's quick, colorful, and absolutely delicious.

View Recipe

24of 38

Broccoli, Lemon, and Gouda Pizzas

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (24)

A fresh-tasting vegetarian pie like this is something we can eat again and again (and again!). Gouda is a surprising but fabulous choice instead of the usual mozzarella, and thin lemon slices offer a zesty punch bite after bite.

View Recipe

25of 38

Pan-Bagnat Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (25)

You don't need to travel to France for a taste of a bistro classic. Chopped anchovies, roasted peppers, capers, and parsley leaves top our classic pizza dough. Only three tablespoons of sauce are used in order to let all of the sharp, salty flavors shine.

View Recipe

26of 38

Zucchini and Caramelized-Onion Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (26)

Summer squash shines alongside feta cheese, Kalamata olives, and mint leaves in this stunning summer pie. Cut down on prep time by using store-bought pizza dough so that you can get dinner on the table in under one hour.

View Recipe

27of 38

"Steak and Egg" Skillet Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (27)

You've never seen a steak and egg entrée like this. Sautéed ground beef, crumbled feta, and white cheddar cheese are scattered on top of the pizza dough. Then comes the real magic—four eggs are cracked right into the meat mixture and baked until set.

View Recipe

28of 38

Skillet Pizza Diavola

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (28)

Craving a deep-dish style pizza? That's where the cast iron skillet really shines. It not only creates a thicker crust, but an incredibly crispy one at that.

View Recipe

29of 38

Tricolor-Salad Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (29)

Crunchy fennel, bright purple radicchio, and peppery baby arugula on top of a classic dough is a wild mix of fabulous flavors. We've substituted cherry tomato halves in place of marinara sauce, because what's a salad without the juicy, bright red fruit?

View Recipe

30of 38

Skillet Pizza with Eggplant and Greens

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (30)

Melt-in-your-mouth roasted eggplant joins garlicky Swiss chard, gooey provolone, and fresh oregano in this show-stopping skillet pizza.

View Recipe

31of 38

Brussels Sprout-Lemon Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (31)

Don't relegate Brussels sprouts to a side dish! They make an excellent pizza topping that's crispy, chewy, and completely addictive. Here, they're punched up with paper-thin lemon slices.

View Recipe

32of 38

Steak Pizza with Peppers and Onions

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (32)

Like a pizza-cheesesteak hybrid! Medium-rare sirloin is teamed with sautéed peppers and onions and Monterey Jack on a golden crust.

View Recipe

33of 38

Ricotta Pizza with Fresh and Roasted Tomatoes

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (33)

A combination of blistered cherry tomatoes and juicy fresh heirlooms adds color and flavor to this white pizza.

View Recipe

34of 38

Spring Vegetable Pizzas

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (34)

Fresh asparagus and cherry tomatoes join two pantry ingredients—tangy marinated artichoke hearts and nutty Gruyère cheese—in this delicious pizza.

View Recipe

35of 38

Pizza with Fresh Figs, Ricotta, Thyme, and Honey

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (35)

Seeking a dessert pizza? Look no further than this elegant whole-wheat number topped with ricotta, thyme, honey, and fresh figs.

View Recipe

36of 38

Three-Cheese Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (36)

Brushing the dough with herb oil as it grills gives this pizza tons of flavor. It's finished with fontina and two kinds of mozzarella.

View Recipe

37of 38

Whole-Wheat Pizzas with Pecorino, Arugula, and Tomatoes

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (37)

A stash of whole-wheat pizza dough in the freezer is like money in the bank! You can pull it out any night of the week and make a quick, crowd-pleasing dinner. Here, the golden crust is topped with crushed grape tomatoes, peppery arugula, and nutty Pecorino Romano.

View Recipe

38of 38

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (38)

Transform everyone's favorite bar snack into a spectacular pizza. Don't forget the blue cheese, celery, and carrot garnish!

View Recipe

Crusts and Toppings Galore: Our Best Pizza Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What are the 5 most popular pizza toppings? ›

Most Popular Pizza Toppings
  1. Pepperoni. This may not come as a surprise, but pepperoni is by far the most popular pizza topping in the United States. ...
  2. Extra Cheese. Also a classic, many Americans order extra cheese on their pies. ...
  3. Mushrooms. ...
  4. Onions. ...
  5. Sausage. ...
  6. Black Olives. ...
  7. Green Peppers. ...
  8. Pineapple.
Nov 10, 2021

What is the secret to the best pizza? ›

11 Essential Tips for Better Pizza | The Food Lab
  • Pick the Right Style.
  • Remember Your Dough-Making Options.
  • For a Better Crust, Try Cold Fermenting.
  • Buy Dough If You're in a Hurry.
  • Use a Rolling Pin If You Need To.
  • Top Your Pies Wisely.
  • Get Your Oven As Hot As You Can.
  • Use a Baking Steel.

What is America's least favorite pizza topping? ›

The survey, which was commissioned by Columbus, Ohio-based pizza chain Donatos and conducted by OnePoll, revealed that the three least-welcome toppings are, in order, anchovies, pineapple, and jalapeno peppers.

What toppings are in Chapter 4 Good Pizza Great Pizza? ›

New ingredients in this chapter are Garlic, Sliced Tomato, and Jalapeno. Plant Lady will introduce the Garden, which will be needed throughout the chapter to harvest the aforementioned ingredients.

What is the best pizza topping of all time? ›

1. Pepperoni. This has long been America's favorite pizza topping.

What is the best cheese to use for homemade pizza? ›

The most commonly used cheese on pizza is mozzarella, because it melts beautifully without turning oily or lumpy. Cheeses such as feta, haloumi and aged gouda are tasty toppings, but they're a bit fancy for families and don't melt as well as mozzarella. Low-moisture mozzarella in particular has great melt and stretch.

What makes pizza crust taste better? ›

The Oil. While not all pizza dough recipes call for oil, Baldwin is a fan. "Don't be afraid to go heavy with olive oil at every step of making your pizza," she says. "It will help crisp up your crust and make it taste great."

What are 3 unusual pizza toppings? ›

Exploring Unconventional Pizza Toppings
  • Beetroot pesto with goat cheese. ...
  • Caramelised onions, apples and goat cheese. ...
  • Breakfast pizza. ...
  • ‍Bacon, sausage, jalapeno and sriracha sauce. ...
  • Rhubarb, basil and apple honey BBQ sauce. ...
  • Grilled honey chicken with sriracha sauce. ...
  • Calamari. ...
  • Red peanut curry.
Aug 8, 2023

What is the number one selling pizza in America? ›

With sales worth approximately 8.57 billion U.S. dollars, Domino's Pizza was the leading quick service pizza chain in the United States in 2022. Pizza Hut and Little Caesars ranked second and third, respectively.

What is the least ordered pizza? ›

The Least Popular Pizza Toppings. While anchovies and pineapple may be the most debated and hated pizza toppings, they aren't alone as the least popular pizza toppings in America. They're in good company alongside these contenders — mushrooms, onions and olives.

What is in a Supreme pizza in Good Pizza Great Pizza? ›

Recipes
Recipe NameUnlockedIngredients
SupremeChapter 1Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
BaconChapter 2Sauce + Cheese + Bacon
PineappleChapter 2Sauce + Cheese + Pineapple
AnchovyChapter 2Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy
30 more rows

What is moo in good pizza great pizza? ›

MOO = Mushroom, Olives, Onion , Sauce and Cheese. Flat Bread = Just the dough. Meat Lovers = Sausage, Pepperoni, Sauce and Cheese, Bacon and Ham. Cheese Tastes weird with Mushrooms = Mushroom Pizza without cheese.

What are the large purple things in good pizza great pizza? ›

Eggplant is a Fruit ingredient unlocked in Chapter 1 as a gift from a special customer. It is the fourth topping available in the game. When ordering, customers may use egg puns, mention breakfast, or refer to them as "large purple tomato things."

What are the top 10 pizza toppings? ›

America's Top 10 Pizza Toppings: A Delicious Ranking!
  • Pepperoni. It's no surprise that America's favorite pizza topping is pepperoni. ...
  • Mushrooms. ...
  • Onions. ...
  • Sausage. ...
  • Bacon. ...
  • Extra Cheese. ...
  • Green Peppers. ...
  • Black Olives.
Jun 7, 2023

What is the most ordered pizza in America? ›

However, according to a survey by YouGov America, pepperoni pizza is by far the most ordered pizza in the United States. Why? Pepperoni has a savory salty taste with just the right amount of spice, has a texture softer than salami, and melds perfectly with a variety of sauces, cheeses, and crust types.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aron Pacocha

Last Updated:

Views: 5506

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aron Pacocha

Birthday: 1999-08-12

Address: 3808 Moen Corner, Gorczanyport, FL 67364-2074

Phone: +393457723392

Job: Retail Consultant

Hobby: Jewelry making, Cooking, Gaming, Reading, Juggling, Cabaret, Origami

Introduction: My name is Aron Pacocha, I am a happy, tasty, innocent, proud, talented, courageous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.